קנדה: האשמות הדדיות בין בלגיה לקנדה מי סיבך את מי בפרשת הליב"ה

לכבוד הרב רבי חיים שאולזאון שליט״א

וויכוח וטענות מוצדקות, שבאמת יכול להיות ששניהם צודקים,

באנטוורפן הכניסו העסקנים עניינים שהם לכאורה עניינים לא להם של המוסדות החרדיים, לתוך הבוץ של אנטוורפן ולהדיון המשפטי שמתקיים שמה, ובלי אישור או רשות כל דהו מצד הקהילה בקנדה,

העובדה שכתוצאה בקנדה מתמודדים כעת עם בעיות קשות מנשוא שמגיעות מצדם של המפלגות הליבלריות ובאיום לסגירות המוסדות החרדיים המוגדרים בפיהם כבלתי חוקיים.

(להלן לינק ווידאו מוטמע שר החינוך הקנדי מאיים בסגירת המוסדות החסידים)

ומנגד העסקנים באנטוורפן טוענים שהעסקנים בקנדה סיבכו את עצמם בגישתם בפרשת לב טהור-הלברנס  ובתמיכה בהם...

לדוגמה מזכירים פעולתיו, כמו הפרסומים בעניין של העסקן החרדי אברהם פרישמן, ושל סאטמר וכיוצא באלה,

יתכן מאד שהאמת הוא באמצע, או ששניהם צודקים,

ימים ידברו.

שבוע טוב

ללינק הקנדי כנסו כאן:

http://ici.radio-canada.ca/nouvelles/societe/2014/04/29/004-hassidiques-education-religieuse-inaction-quebec.shtml 

These Hasidic fleeing illegal schools

Updated Tuesday, April 29, 2014 till 18h 44 EDT

Exclusive - Yohan Shiffra and grew up in a Hasidic community before leaving for their children to have access to secular education, so that they escape what they call intellectual prison. Stations of the Cross that would have been easier if Quebec had applied the Act on Public Education, they denounce.

The report 's Émilie Dubreuil

In 2006, Radio-Canada reported that thousands of Hasidic Jewish children were enrolled in contravention of the Act on Public Education. Thousands of children who attend religious schools exclusively and do not meet the mandatory programs.

Access to education up to age 16, a right of the child in Quebec. However, despite the promises of the various governments, the situation has hardly changed.

A situation Shiffra lived. She braved many storms in order to pick up his children in this school.French schools, the Commission scolaire de Montreal (CSDM), where children learn mathematics, history, geography.

Immigrants from the inside

When Shiffra Yohan and decide to leave their community, the family spoke only Yiddish. Shiffra learned French in a center for immigrants in Côte-des-Neiges. "Yiddish is also a tactic to be very cut off from the world. This way, children do not have access to other information. "

Yohan her husband remains angry against Quebec. Although they both grew up in Boisbriand, he never had a lesson in math, English or French. Only religious education, which is contrary to the Act on Public Education.

"I am a survivor. [...] The Quebec politicians are guilty of my ignorance, and I resent them. "- Yohan

In 1963, 18 families Tosh community settled in this municipality north segment of the crown of Montreal because their leader, Rabbi Lowy wants his followers to isolate what he calls "the bad influences of the city."

Fifty years later, Tosh are Boisbriand 3000.

"My mother had 11 children. And I wanted to do more, because it's like a competition. This is the only value of a woman in the community do a lot of soldiers for God. "- Shiffra

"As a prison"

Despite the fact that their union is the result of an arranged marriage, and Yohan Shiffra love.They have four children. But gradually, doubt sets. They thirst for knowledge and freedom, especially for their children.

"My husband and I, we decided that it was very important for children to have a good education, and I was hoping to Montreal, there would be more accessible. There, there was only a school, but this is not really a school. "- Shiffra

"Every week there is a different portion of the Bible that practice, and that's all we do all day.There are no sports, no things like school, explains the mother. This is not a stimulus to the brain is like a prison. "

Education reviled

However, the law is clear: all children have the right to be educated under an educational system established by the Ministry of Education.

However, no schools for boys Tosh Boisbriand appears in the records of the Ministry. Which is quite consistent with the Hasidic tradition. The boys must be dedicated to the study of religious texts.

Shiffra

"In my community, it is very serious to have an education [...]. It is against the culture, because if we know too much out of it makes a friction. [...] We're not going to submit to all things which demand. "- Shiffra

In addition, one of the girls' schools has lost his license last year.

Other communities

The Situation Tosh is not unique. In Outremont and Mile End, the Satmar also refuse secular education for boys and girls. While schools Skver community only allowed for girls. Yet, for years, many politicians are committed to resolve the issue.

The Ministry of Education, declined to comment on the case.

We know that in Quebec continues against Yeshiva Toras Moishe, a primary school for boys in the Satmar community, for its refusal to teach core subjects. The case will be heard next fall.Counsel for the school intends to argue that clients should receive exemptions respect for their religious beliefs.

For the husband Shiffra, the argument of respect for religious beliefs is misleading.

"Those who say that forcing children into school Hasidic comes to anti-Semitism, I say anti-Semitism, according to me, is not to help the Jews to be school children. "- Yohan

In recent years, more and more young people choose to leave their Hasidic communities. On discussion forums, some "ex" evoke the idea of ​​class actions to have been deprived of education.This is the case in Israel and the State of New York.

Difficult calculation illegal schools

is difficult to say how many Hasidic schools enroll children in alternative schools. Several groups live in Montreal, and each has its schools. The main ones are: Tosh arrived in Quebec in 1951, they settled in Boisbriand in 1963 They are now 3000 A school for girls, the academy Beth Tziril, lost his license in June 2013 they were then... 123 secondary and 213 primary.schools for boys are not even identified by the Department. And we do not know how there.After a schism within the group, some parents have opened a secret school in a house near the community. Satmar The Community installed mainly in Outremont since the 50s, which has a few thousand people. Beth Esther Academy has lost his license in June 2012. At that time, 244 students were enrolled. government continues primary school boys for refusing to teach core subjects. The case should be heard in the fall. Moreover, impossible to find the boys 13 years and older. Especially here, too, there was a schism in the community. It is therefore likely that the Department is unaware of some schools. Skver The Small community of Russian origin as established in Outremont. Girls' schools have licenses, not those of boys. The community comes to buy Bovril building at the corner of Park Avenue and Bernard Street to house these yeshivas. At primary, the last time they had a permit in 2011-2012, 105 children were enrolled. Belz The Community located in Mile End. All schools still have a license. But inspectors found in August 2013 that the number of hours devoted to compulsory subjects was still deficient. According to the statement, the schools had 252 girls and 277 boys in primary and 281 secondary school girls and boys. 's Lubavitch community Hasidic most populous Montreal, located in Côte-des-Neiges since 1941. Its schools are legal. However, the latest report of the management of private education (2011-2012) mentions significant gaps in the education provided to boys, especially in terms of teaching time. In the same report, it is stated that five boys' schools had to comply with the law before September 2012. However, the latest report from 2012 to 2013 has not yet been published. The Department refused to say whether this group of five has complied, or what are the schools.